Fit for a Queen: Sideless Surcotes in the 15th Century

It’s often quoted in reenactment circles that the sideless surcoat that became popular in the 14th century, or surcote overt, was such a scandalous article of clothing to warrant contemporary church officials describing them as the “Gates of Hell.” In the mid-14th century, Dominican friar John Bromyard described them in his sermon: “Christ opened his side for the redemption and salvation of many, And these others open their side for lascivious and carnal provocation, and for the perdition of those who behold them.”

While this may suggest that it was a racy and controversial garment, Bromyard and other clergy found issue with many facets of women’s dress, from cleavage to headdresses to long trains. In fact, by the end of the 14th century, artistic representations of these surcoats suggest the connotations of such garments was actually quite the opposite: sideless surcoats are often seen on queens, brides, virgins, and saints.

Characteristics of 15th century Sideless Surcoats

The sideless surcoat peaked in popularity from the mid to late 14th century, and over time transitioned to being a garment worn almost exclusively for ceremonial occasions. As such, there weren’t massive changes in how these surcoats are depicted from 1400 to 1500. 

From artistic representations, most sideless surcoats in the 15th century appear to be lined in fur.  This lining is almost exclusively white, and many representations appear to be ermine, a highly prized and expensive fur associated with the highest nobility and royalty. 

Detail, Grandes Heures d’Anne de Bretagne. BNF Latin 9474, fol. 203v.

Continuing a trend from the late-14th century, the front of surcoats continued to be fairly narrow, with many surcoats only visibly showing fur on top, holding up the main skirt fabric. Many had a plastron embellished with jewels or ornaments as well. The skirts themselves were long and the sumptuous fabrics generously pooling around the feet of the wearer certainly would have been a major show of wealth.

The surcoat would be worn over a close-fitting cote, often paired with a gilded belt.

Representations in Art

By the 15th century, the wearer of a sideless surcoat in a piece of art was someone of special status- often royal, sainted, or a bride. 

There are many instances of earthly queens being seen in surcoats.In De Mulierbus Claris (BNF Fr. 598), dating to the early 15th century, several legendary queens are depicted wearing sideless surcoats. In one example, Queen Chiomara (fol. 101v) is shown wearing a red surcoat with a white fur top and lined in the same. She appears to have jewels down the front of the surcoat, which is worn over a burgundy gown. She also wears a golden belt under the surcoat, and a golden crown upon her head.  

In folio 159, we see a later example in Jean I of Naples, wearing an ermine-lined surcoat with a royal blue bottom and a jeweled plastron, while donning a crown and a scepter.

Another example is the representation of Queen Elizabeth Woodville in the Guildbook of the London Skinners’ Fraternity of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary (GL MS 31692 — c.1472). She is quite queenly in her surcoat which is accompanied by a crown, ball and scepter. Her hair is long and worn down, in a symbol of purity. Worn underneath an ermine lined mantle, her red surcoat is also lined in ermine and matches her red under gown. 

Queen Elizabeth Woodville in the Guildbook of the London Skinners’ Fraternity of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary (GL MS 31692 — c.1472

While often symbolically representing queens, the gown was not limited to literal royalty. The most common non-royal figures to wear surcoats are saints. As “Queens of Heaven,” it’s common for female saints, particularly virgins, to wear surcoats. St, Catherine in particular is frequently portrayed this way. Echoing the theme of ceremonial importance and virginity, surcoats are also often seen denoting brides, both royal and non-royal.

St Catherine, St. John Altarpiece by Hans Memling, 1474-79
Grandes Heures d’Anne de Bretagne c. 1508

AS a Status Symbol

In _____, ______ and his family are depicted wearing representational clothing for their status in life. The women are shown wearing sideless surcotes. ____ apparently had a reputation of dressing above his status, suggesting that he may have wanted his family shown as a pinnacle of nobility. While he may have wanted to allude to their wealth and status, had there been a restriction on surcoats to just royalty that would have been more boundary pushing to depict them in this way. 

Many funerary brasses in England also show noble women wearing sideless surcoats. These are often accompanied by large headdresses, and long mantles. Heraldic designs were popular, although whether these are an artistic identifier or a representation of actual clothes is unclear. 

The nobles who decided to pay for a funerary monument were only a small fraction of the aristocracy, but the clothes they are depicted in were chosen as how they’d be represented for eternity. This choice must have held some weight and can therefore shine some insight on what the person valued.  The choice of a sideless surcote could have been because of its ceremonial designation, its artistic connection to “queens of heaven” (particularly being situated within a church), or as a show of wealth. 

Coronation of Phillipa of Hainault , Froissart’s Chronicles (BNF Fr. 2675, fol. 27), second quarter of the 15th century

Making the Surcoat

Patterns/References:

  • Past Patterns
  • Period Costumes for Stage and Screen 1, Jean Hunniset
  • Froissart, Français 2646,

Supplies:

  • Brocade from Sartor
  • Scraps of white/silver mink from
  • Silk for lining (from stash)

My goal for this outfit, much like its purpose in the 15th century, was primarily for wearing to court or other ‘special occasions.’

I started off by making a mock-up, starting with the Past Patterns pattern, and then altering the style based on the illustration in Froissart (Fr 2646). Its not a terribly complicated garment, so it would be pretty easy to draft yourself, but I had the pattern sitting in my sewing room already, so why reinvent the wheel.

I ended up adjusting the height and where the openings hit on my body- I liked how it looked with the opening ending right at the widest point of my hip. I adjusted the shape of the curves just a bit, particularly around the boobs so the surcoat width at the bust was essentially nipple to nipple. I found this avoided fit problems going around the bust if it was wider, but any narrower and I felt it made me look wider, which I wanted to avoid. The last alteration was to adjust the slope of the shoulder, just to improve the way the garment hung on my body.

Selected Bibliography

Beal, Jane. ed., Becoming the Pearl-Poet: Perceptions, Connections, Receptions. (Studies in Medieval Literature.) Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2022.

Chambers, Mark. “‘Hys Surcote Was Ouert’: The ‘Open Surcoat’ in Late Medieval British Texts.” In Medieval Clothing and Textiles 7, edited by Gale R. Owen-Crocker and Robin Netherton. Medieval Clothing and Textiles. Boydell & Brewer, 2011. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781846159510.005.

Dufresne, Laura Rinaldi. “Christine de Pizan’s ‘Treasure of the City of Ladies’: A Study of Dress and Social Hierarchy.” Woman’s Art Journal 16, no. 2 (1995): 29–34. https://doi.org/10.2307/1358572.

“Full Text of ‘The Coronation and Churching of Queen Philippa in the Fourth Year of the Reign of Edward III of England, Including an Unpublished Great Wardrobe Indenture Relating to These Occasions.’” Accessed January 30, 2026. https://archive.org/stream/McMurchy1976/McMurchy1976_djvu.txt.

Gittos, Brian and Moira. “Interpreting Medieval Effigies: The Evidence from Yorkshire to 1400.” Oxbow Publishing, 2021.

Jack, Kimberly. “What Is the Pearl-Maiden Wearing, and Why?” In Medieval Clothing and Textiles 7, edited by Gale R. Owen-Crocker and Robin Netherton. Medieval Clothing and Textiles. Boydell & Brewer, 2011. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781846159510.004.

“Sideless Surcoats and Giorneas.” http://www.larsdatter.com/surcoats.htm.

The J. Paul Getty Museum in Los Angeles. “Philosophy Presenting the Seven Liberal Arts to Boethius (Getty Museum).” Accessed January 30, 2026. https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/108F61.

“The Many Mi-Parti Variations in 14th Century Medieval Manuscripts | Athenaeum – Presented by the Barony of Madrone.” Athenaeum, June 7, 2021. https://athenaeum.baronyofmadrone.net/exhibits/the-many-mi-parti-variations-in-14th-century-medieval-manuscripts/.

Walker, Pam. “Medieval Bling: The Display of Jewellery on Women’s Funerary Monuments from England in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries.” Acta Ad Archaeologiam et Artium Historiam Pertinentia 33, no. 19 N.S. (2021): 289–304. https://doi.org/10.5617/acta.10447.

Leave a Reply